Have you ever had to terminate an employee's employment? Can you discuss the steps you took prior to making that decision?

Question

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

Creating performance review document
 * I began by creating performance document which contained information about
   the review and evidences of not meeting expectations consistently. 4 releases
   out of 6 got delayed in 1 quarter.
 * Added information about the concrete feedbacks shared in 1:1’s and in monthly
   reviews.

Discussion with HR
 * Data points which I had gathered showed that the responsibilities were not
   met on a consistent basis even after specific feedbacks were shared to work
   on the areas of improvements.
 * We both agreed on that the role needsadjusting of processes for the team
   proactive risk identification and mitigation
   effective communication
   
 * We had a PIP policy in place for low performers. We discussed and decided to
   put the EM on PIP for a month

PIP plan
 * For PIP discussion I started to identify, timelines, review process and
   specific areas where I want EM to show improvement as per the expectations
   form the role.One check metric was defined that pulse rating of the team
   should not drop.
   
 * Got it reviewed with HR again to ensure it is as per the company policy.
 * Expectation setting : Scheduled a meeting with the EM  and had a concise
   discussion about the PIP. What are the expectations, the review process and
   outcome.This was clearly communicated that this situation will be handled
   with professionalism and privacy. The objective is to make sure the EM works
   as per the expectations of the role and I as the leader of the group and the
   company wants EM to succeed.

Reviews
 * Setup a biweekly review meeting as we discussed along involving HR, EM and
   myself.
 * We connected after 2 weeks, we could see that the EM made some progress but
   overall was under a lot of pressure and still there was gaps.
 * I saw a high risk of PIP goal not getting met. After this I started working
   on a backup plan to identify who can take over the team instantly and planned
   for a replacement [as this was a different stream of work] . This EM had
   worked on this product during kickoff stage and had big overlap with
   stakeholders.
 * We had one last meeting where the goals were discussed and we found the EM to
   be short on delivery, stakeholder mgmt and effectively navigating team. I
   communicated the shortcomings and the process forward. Our HR team had a
   process of asking employees to resign in such situations, so that they can
   maintain the dignity. EM was relieved on the same day and was provided last
   day confirmation mail and exp letter. Other info about dues and Full and
   final was communicated by HR.

After exit plan:
 * Setup a meeting with a manager and seeking manager’s input about if EM can
   fill in for the time being on the day of exit of previous Manager
 * Having a discussion within leadership team of my group and communicating
   about this decisions to all
 * Setup a call the next day with the team and introduced the EM who has decided
   to step in and help navigate the team.
 * Worked closely with the EM about the team matters to not overwhelm EM

Anonymous · Answer

Situation (20 seconds): "After Stripe acquired TaxJar, I inherited a senior
engineer who'd been a staff tech lead at TaxJar. Despite strong technical
credentials, they struggled adapting to Stripe's culture and scale, affecting
team morale and project delivery."

Task (15 seconds): "As their manager, I needed to either help them succeed in a
new environment or make a difficult transition decision while maintaining team
productivity on our critical data ingestion pipeline project."

Action (90 seconds): "I took a systematic, empathetic approach over three
months:

First, I demonstrated Humility to build trust by acknowledging the difficulty of
their transition. We documented clear expectations at company, team, and
individual levels, mapping their interests to our opportunities. I created a
6-month growth plan together with them.

Initially, I assigned them to a gRPC project leveraging their TaxJar expertise
to integrate Stripe Tax with TaxJar’s reporting and filing services - they met
expectations in this work and got more exposure to working with other Senior+
Stripe engineers. However, when they moved to their next priority and began
co-authoring our 0-to-1 3rd party data ingestion pipeline design, red flags
emerged. They consistently pushed back with 'at TaxJar we already solved this'
without proposing constructive alternatives. This showed lack of Growth Mindset.

I addressed this directly but privately - explaining that senior leaders must
propose solutions, not just critique. They were able to add some valuable
contributions to the design, but when execution started they continued focusing
on low-leverage TaxJar maintenance work instead of leading our highest-priority
project, leaving three engineers without clear direction. This resulted in my
need to escalate.

Demonstrating Trust through transparency, I shared everything I had documented
and consulted HR and my skip-level. Given Stripe's philosophy on PIPs - only
using them when turnaround is likely - HR suggested I offer a generous exit
package instead. The engineer accepted, admitting they'd already been job
searching.

To maintain Balance and team health, we negotiated a graceful week-long
transition where they could say goodbyes without disparaging anyone."

Result (30 seconds): "Despite losing about a week of productivity, I found a new
project DRI and we delivered the project on time with the replacement lead. This
individual later earned our team's first 'Greatly Exceeds' rating and Staff
promotion, largely based on the ownership they took over this project. Team
morale improved significantly - they told me removing the negative influence and
TaxJar distractions increased focus and growth opportunities. This taught me
that protecting team culture sometimes means making hard decisions quickly
rather than prolonging inevitable departures."

Anonymous · Answer

Creating performance review document and added evidence of not meeting
expectations on a consistent basis.
 * Added information about the feedbacks shared
 * Goals created along with the timelines
 * Evidence of non compliance

Discussed with HR about the employee and got inputs. If allowed by company
policy put employee on PIP.
PIP discussion to have info about goal, timelines, review and clear
communication about the outcome if the goals are not met.
If still non compliance, work with HR to discuss about severance if applicable,
option to provide guardian leave, or handling the termination letter.
Scheduled a meeting with the employee with HR present and clearly communicating
about the job termination and the benefits being provided, placement support,
insurance, severance etc.

Anonymous · Answer

At Centercard, As a director of tech, I was growing my team and hired a Sr. Dev.
While this person had right technical chops, was not a team player, He had
arguments with team members and PMs. Would not collobrate and acccept mistakes -
this create a toxic environment. Despite my effort to choach in 1:1 and warnings
that he should course correct, he would not change his behavior - by providing
examples on where he could be more collobrative insted of combative. Inspite of
this he did not change his beahvior, I gathered feedback from my team mates and
PM and presented the facts to my manager and HR, it was decided to let him go.I
had to do a retrosepctive and found that we had indexed heavily on technical
skills in the interview process, I proposed that we have a behavior round
interviews so that we choose one with right technical skills and culture fit.

Anonymous · Answer

At Centercard, As a director of tech, I was growing my team and hired a Sr. Dev.
While this person had right technical chops, was not a team player, He had
arguments with team members and PMs. Would not collobrate and acccept mistakes -
this create a toxic environment. Despite my effort to choach in 1:1 and warnings
that he should course correct, he would not change his behavior. I raised this
to my manager and HR and we decided to let him go. I had to do a retrosepctive
and found that we had indexed heavily on technical skills in the interview
process, I proposed that we have a behavior round interviews so that we choose
one with right technical skills and culture fit.

Anonymous · Answer

At Centercard, As a director of tech, I was growing my team and hired a Sr. Dev.
While this person had right technical chops, was not a team player, He had
arguments with team members and PMs. Would not collobrate and acccept mistakes -
this create a toxic environment. Despite my effort to choach in 1:1 would not
change his behavior. I raised this to my manager and HR and we decided to let
him go. I had to do a retrosepctive and found that we had indexed heavily on
technical skills in the interview process, I proposed that we have a behavior
round interviews so that we choose one with right technical skills and culture
fit.

Anonymous · Answer

We have an individual in our team whose performance was not up to standard from
the beginning. It was identified and I discussed with him about a 3 month plan
to improve and gave weekly targets. I closely monitored the performance and in
the end it was satisfactory. So I let him continue.

A year later, went through similar unsatisfactory performance again. This time
an update was made to the algorithm during my long leave and it was terrible.
Instead of rolling back the update a decision was made to stop the algorithm.
When I came back, I got to know about it and reverted the change and fixed the
problem. This time I went to HR and gave him a plan to improve. This time I
noticed  the performance was good only when we are behind him.

Lastly we ran into another situation and a PIP was initiated and later we
terminated the employee.

KARANJOT SIDHU · Answer

Yes. I did. That should be cautious decision. I took a look at their code review
comments, code contributions, the program that he led, Quality of deliverables,
peer feedback, previous work history, feedback from previous managers and made
decisions based on it.

Have you ever had to terminate an employee's employment? Can you discuss the steps you took prior to making that decision?

Practice this question with AI

Go Premium

Community Answers

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Unlock Full Access

Practice More Questions